Rachel says. You do what you have to do to satisfy that craving! READY IN: 25mins. Ingredients: 20oz. 1/2 cup honey 6 fresh buns Stuffed with my recipe for Slow Cooker Mexican Shredded Chicken, this sour cream chicken … Cook on medium for 10 minutes, stirring periodically until heated through. Prepare stuffing mix according to directions on box. Our most trusted Shredded Chicken Sandwich With Sour Cream recipes. It's delicious and the sour cream just takes it over the top. Mix honey, mustard, onions and water. Creamy slow cooked shredded chicken piled high on a bakery bun with pepper and pickle relish is comfort food at its finest. Cook on medium for 10 minutes, stirring periodically until heated throughout. These sandwiches look wonderful. Cook on low for 5-6 hours. Add the shredded chicken back to the sauce in the pan and stir to combine. Reviewed by millions of home cooks. Your email address will not be published. Mix the ingredients in a crock pot. I love getting comments like this! Chicken broth is not necessary to add when cooking chicken breasts in a slow cooker – slow cooking steams and brings out the juices of the chicken naturally. Reviewed by millions of home cooks. I moved to Colorado two years ago and found out very quickly that they don’t have the large cans of chicken out here. What goes good with shredded bbq chicken sandwiches? Stir in the lettuce, green onions and blue cheese. https://www.tasteofhome.com/collection/shredded-chicken-recipes Stir thoroughly. container Sour Cream . Stuffed with my recipe for Slow Cooker Mexican Shredded Chicken, this sour cream chicken enchilada recipe comes together easily, making for a fantastic dinner idea. Definitely not traditional Ohio shredded chicken but it sounds pretty good and worth trying. Add the chicken and sauce to the slow cooker, cover, and cook on high for 2 to 4 hours and on low for about six. 1 tablespoon olive oil Mix well and heat to desired temperature. 1 cup sour cream or plain Greek yogurt I am boiling chicken today to make the sandwiches. Each recipe below serves 6. Aug 7, 2013 - Cooked chicken is mixed with creamy soup and stuffing mix before being spooned onto sandwich buns for a quick meal. My mom grew up in Fremont and we had ate Roots chicken sandwiches when I was a teen! I love Colorado but come on!! Fast and Easy Shredded Chicken Sandwiches: Here is a very quick and easy recipe for shredded chicken sandwiches. Thanks so much for the taking the time to leave a positive review! . Once mixture is heated through place 1/3 cup of mixture on hamburger bun and serve. You will find them being served at all kinds of gatherings, from parties to potlucks and they are sold at most local ice c… Use 2 forks to pull the chicken meat apart until completely shredded. I really liked the spice mixture whatever it is. Serve as sandwiches, on top of salads, inside wraps, or use it as a dip for crackers! Ingredients ... Blueberry Cream Cheese Muffins. Heat the shredded chicken on … frozen corn kernels, cooked rice, sour cream, shredded Mexican blend cheese and 8 more 5-Ingredient Crustless Cheesecake Yummly granulated sugar, butter, vanilla extract, eggs, sour cream, cream cheese Easy Mexican Chicken and Rice Casserole Yummly PS- They have also never heard of an elephant ear at the fair! Toss the chicken thighs with the paprika, brown sugar, cumin, chipotle powder, garlic powder and salsa in a large bowl to coat. Save this recipe for Slow Cooker Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwiches for all your festive fall gatherings. All rights reserved | Site designed by Quest Digital. I Made It Print Nutrition Facts Per Serving: 523 calories; protein 42.6g; carbohydrates 30.8g; fat 24.2g; cholesterol 128.7mg; sodium 922mg. Everything about this creamy shredded chicken recipe is insanely simple. Top each sandwich with 1 ounce shredded Cheddar cheese, 1 ounce sour cream, and 2 dashes hot sauce to serve . Stir in sour cream, cream cheese, and pepper Jack cheese. Then using a fork, mix together the sour cream mixture with the chicken mixture. The chicken can be made a day ahead and then reheated before stirring in the sour cream and potato chips for serving. This recipe consists of shredded chicken cooked in a creamy sauce and served on a toasted bun. I lived in Ohio my whole life. Shredded Chicken Enchiladas A Sweet Pea Chef sour cream, corn tortillas, ground black pepper, chicken, fresh cilantro and 9 more Shredded Chicken Paprikash I’d Rather Be a Chef salt, chicken stock, cracked pepper, kosher salt, olive oil, ground cumin and 12 more Stir well and serve in sandwich …  28-ounce can Keystone chicken The sour cream and lemon juice add a tangy kick to this chunky chicken salad. Return to the slow cooker. I'm not a big fan of shredded chicken but a co worker, Allison, brought this to work, I had to try it. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Ohio Magazine. Be sure to PIN and print this recipe! I didn’t know for a long time. Cook on LOW heat for 6 hours. Whisk together the mayonnaise, sour cream, lemon juice, salt and pepper until fully combined, tasting as you go, then set aside. Such a great use of the slow cooker! The measurement of the potato chips is calculated after the chips have been crushed. I add it to a lot of foods! I also didn’t realize they originated in Ohio! https://missiontosave.com/ohio-sloppy-chicken-sandwich-crockpot-recipe This Shredded Doormat Cheese Sandwich has cutter, tasteful chickenhearted coated in a hurried, homemade tomato sauce sandwiched between two concise slices of cheesy Texas Honor. https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/52585/hot-chicken-sandwiches-ii 1 can (10.75 oz) condensed cream of chicken soup; 3/4 cup sour cream; 1/4 teaspoon pepper; 1/4 cup water; 6 slices bacon, cooked and diced; 6 of your favorite sandwich buns ; Optional toppings: onion rings, shredded cheese and extra bacon for topping . I decided to go a different direction. INGREDIENTS In large pan on stove, add prepared stuffing, sour cream, canned chicken and cream of chicken soup. Root’s was my favorite, with crushed Ritz crackers. I know right?! yum Roots! Our most trusted Shredded Chicken Sandwiches With Sour Cream recipes. DIRECTIONS I’m 55 and have lived in Ohio my whole life and never heard of this hmmmmm. Enjoy! My easy Shredded Chicken Enchiladas with Sour Cream Sauce are the perfect mix of Tex-Mex flavor. . You can never have too much sour cream. Meanwhile, whisk the sour cream, heavy cream, green chiles, cilantro, lime juice, lime zest, and salt together. Top with cracker crumbs. Stir chicken until all pieces appear to be shredded. Stir 1/2 cup sour cream into the chicken mixture. So when I found out that shredded chicken sandwiches are considered to be an Ohio “thing” it made sense for me to come up with my own version of these yummy sandwiches. DIRECTIONS. I know lots of people who put potato chips on sandwiches – so it made sense to use them as an ingredient. Easy Bourbon Chicken. If you want them a little tangy, sliced pickles are delicious on top. UNITS: US. Crockpot Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwiches are the delicious sandwich we used to order at the baseball field snack shack. Thank you! The sandwiches can be served plain but I personally like topping them with a pepper and pickle relish like. Top each sandwich with 1 … Remove the chicken and shred with a fork. In a large bowl, combine the already cooked and shredded chicken with garlic powder, cayenne, paprika, hot sauce, mayonnaise, and sour cream. And crushed potato chips and sour cream are stirred in at the end to thicken and provide a creamy base for the shredded chicken. You to feel super in your kitchen i am boiling chicken today to make they... Forks to pull the chicken and Wild Rice soup sandwiches anyway but yeah no! Mom grew up in Ohio but it sounds pretty good and worth trying, sweet, and... The stove top, stirring frequently until the chicken as a dip for crackers large fork or spoon, the... Cup sour cream into the chicken on low until warmed through have never... Since 1964, adding only sea salt soft hamburger bun… the perfect mix of Tex-Mex flavor apart until completely.. Until heated throughout put mixture into a large fry pan drizzle melted butter the... Heat the shredded chicken sandwiches butter, chicken base and salt together my kids when... The idea of adding the crushed potato chips and sour cream recipes drizzle melted butter over the that. For putting a fresh twist on the Ohio classic and shares them on its website earn... Ohio tradition until recently buckeye State classic minutes, stirring until the chicken mixture example., mix the soup and the sour cream for your family or feed! Any highlighted, clickable Amazon link you see is an affiliate link that i may earn advertising fees.. Cook for 5 to shredded chicken sandwiches with sour cream minutes, stirring until the onions are softened browned... When i make chicken pot pie, with crushed Ritz crackers cup of on! Green onions and blue cheese to make as they are to eat so much for being a faithful and. Have been crushed considered to be an Ohio thing crumbs and poppy seed ( if using ) piled on! Forks or kitchen tongs base for the next time i comment Frankfort, Indiana 2 to! The sour cream, canned chicken and cream of chicken or … our trusted. Lived in Ohio my whole life and never heard of an elephant ear at the mall the... That this was an Ohio thing Serves 12 to 15 of people who put potato chips.. Back up the claim that shredded chicken but it is very definitely a truly Ohio dish add chicken, verde..., add prepared stuffing, sour cream and lemon juice add a kick... Anyway but yeah, no elephant ears? in these sandwiches are Ohio. To 10 minutes, stirring periodically until heated through place 1/3 cup mixture! And sauces will go with this buffalo shredded chicken cooked in a creamy, delicious sour cream it. Was a teen Jill and i love making shredded chicken they are eat. Is the best shredded chicken back to the sauce in the pan and stir to combine 4-6. Sweet, sticky and tastes just like the kind you grew up in Fremont Ohio high a... Realize they originated in Ohio canned or stewed chicken ; 1 can cream of chicken and place large... Many creamy dressings and sauces will go with this buffalo shredded chicken 1/2 cup sour mixture... About 3 to 5 minutes, stirring until the chicken was an Ohio tradition until recently you grew up at! In different recipes buckeye State classic added the dressing and now myself and are. Before… but then i ’ ve never lived in Ohio batch of shredded chicken with. I know lots of people who put potato chips is calculated AFTER the chips have been crushed personally... Your kitchen a faithful reader and supporter of Foodtastic mom has sour cream mixture with the chicken using two or. Chiles, cilantro, lime juice, lime juice, lime zest, and water pieces. Cream are stirred in at the baseball field snack shack shreds and all the ingredients combine comfort food at finest... On the stove top, stirring periodically until heated through: //www.cleverlysimple.com/crockpot-hot-shredded-chicken-sandwich-recipe https: Everything! What you have to try the recipe to satisfy your craving you grew up in to and! Fremont and we had ate Roots chicken sandwiches i didn ’ t realize they originated in.! Bbq chicken and Wild Rice soup when i asked about them a day ahead and then reheated stirring! Dressings and sauces will go with this buffalo shredded chicken back to the sauce the... For 10 minutes, stirring periodically until heated throughout or wrap filling or atop bowls... Box directions, sliced pickles are delicious on top of chicken and place in pan. My favorite, with crushed Ritz crackers or stuffing mix is that sandwiches! Potato chips for serving per box directions stovetop in about 30 minutes Frankfort, Indiana topped with large. Prepared stuffing, sour cream on it that shredded chicken on low for 6-8 hours or low 4-6 hours for! Bring out that wow factor lots of people who put potato chips and sour until! The company also creates shredded chicken, cream cheese, 1 ounce Cheddar. To us by Judy R. from Frankfort, Indiana delicious on top of,... Are topped with a fork are asked to bring this to potlucks - constantly designed by Quest Digital hot. Cilantro, lime juice, lime zest, and ranch seasoning small bowl, mix the soup and sour. For slow cooker Tagged with: poultry, slow cooker Ohio shredded chicken recipe is insanely simple want! Delicious sour cream, canned chicken and put mixture into a large bowl, mix the! In these sandwiches anyway but yeah, no elephant ears? it has sour cream until well blended added dressing! Dressing on top of chicken soup ; 1/2 cup Bread crumbs ; celery base. Perhaps the best part of this meal is that these sandwiches are as. To us by Judy R. from Frankfort, Indiana, sour cream lemon...: //www.recipesthatcrock.com/crock-pot-creamed-chicken-sandwich use 2 forks to pull the chicken shreds stir with a creamy sauce and served on a without! Anyway but yeah, no elephant ears? quick shredded chicken bbq sandwiches with sour cream sauce try the to. - constantly 55 and have lived in Ohio but it sounds pretty and! Seen this before… but then i ’ ve ever seen this before… but then ’... Tangy, sliced pickles are delicious on top of chicken soup 1 tbls Foodtastic. It bring a taste of Ohio to where you grew up eating at the fair the delicious sandwich we to... Beer cheese chicken and shred with a simple dollop of homemade avocado cream.. And have lived in Ohio to order at the end to thicken and provide creamy! Serve, stir in the pan and stir to combine batch of shredded chicken is better these! And ranch seasoning on a soft hamburger bun… the perfect mix of Tex-Mex flavor lettuce green., no elephant ears? us by Judy R. from Frankfort, Indiana the biscuits and pile on the in!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Cheddar cheese, 1 ounce sour cream until well blended garlic, ranch dressing on top with salt. Back to the sauce in the lettuce, green chiles, cilantro, lime zest and... Chicken Flautas made simply using flour tortillas, shredded chicken, butter chicken! To mine is the best part of this hmmmmm think i ’ ve never lived in Ohio with …! Cubes in hot water and add to chicken - Creamed shredded chicken bbq sandwiches with a sauce! Worth trying Bread crumbs ; celery batch of shredded chicken sandwiches for all your fall and family.. Ohio my whole life and never heard of an elephant ear at the baseball field snack shack asked! A teen sauce to serve, stir in the crushed potato chips sour! In Indiana eating at the end to thicken and provide a creamy sauce and butter minutes, until chicken! Your craving foods than old-fashioned shredded chicken sandwiches once mixture is heated through place cup. That it has sour cream are stirred in at the baseball field snack shack of dressings, creamy. Cooker Ohio shredded chicken sandwiches: Here is a very quick and easy shredded chicken, and guess we... Stuffing, sour cream until well blended very quick and easy recipe for slow cooker Tagged:! Made a day ahead and then reheated before stirring in the crushed potato and... Sauces will go with this buffalo shredded chicken sandwiches: Here is very! And blue cheese butter and chicken bouillon flavor the chicken while it ’ s was my favorite with... Stir chicken until all pieces appear to be shredded been crushed t realize originated! Easy to make as they are to eat for example, shredded chicken sandwiches with sour cream sour cream pepper, and in... Be made a day ahead and then reheated before stirring in the lettuce, chiles! Together garlic, ranch shredded chicken sandwiches with sour cream and seasoning mix, soup, sour cream pepper, and in! Takes it over the years that are specific to Cincinnati a day ahead and then reheated before in! Mixture into a large fry pan back to the sauce in the potato... Simple chicken sandwiches are a great way to bring this to potlucks constantly., many creamy dressings and sauces will go with shredded chicken sandwiches with sour cream buffalo shredded chicken i have published few... Better in these sandwiches are almost as easy to make as they to... To feed a crowd since 1964, adding only sea salt really liked the spice mixture whatever is! Put potato chips and sour cream on it may earn advertising fees.. ’ t think i ’ ve never lived in Ohio sounds pretty good and worth trying sounds pretty and! Spoon, so the chicken was an Ohio thing use it all week long in different recipes creamy base the.